Randy McDonald ([info]rfmcdpei) wrote,
@ 2004-02-23 21:07:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current mood:mildly bloggish
Current music:Sinéad O'Connor, "Nothing Compares 2 U"

[BRIEF NOTE] Ottawan Sociolinguistics
Ottawa has long had a bilingual history. When I went in Ottawa's Terry Fox Centre in 1997, though, as much as I looked around the Terry Fox Centre in eastern Ottawa I didn't see much evidence of this bilingualism. Things were rather different this time, perhaps because I wandered more around central downtown Ottawa. My 1997 experience led me to compare Ottawa disfavourably to Moncton; this time, things went in the different direction. (There aren't many Francophone Maghrebin or African immigrants in Moncton, for instance, and rather fewer French-language signs.) It's interesting that this is so, not least because one-third of the populations of both the Ottawa-Hull and the Moncton Census Metropolitan Areas speak French as a first language, with half of both CMA population being bilingual.

The secret to this might lie in the uneven distribution of Francophones in the Ottawa CMA. This analysis of census data suggests that on the Québec side of the Ottawa river, 15.8% of the quarter-million residents were Anglophone, while on the Ontario side, a shade under 150 thousand of the eight hundred thousand Ottawans are Francophone. Aylmer on the Québec side is one-third Anglophone; Clarence-Rockland on the Ontario side is three-fifths Francophone, while Russell is part of a larger Francophone territory directly contiguous with Québec, and other enclaves assimilated into the city of Ottawa like Vanier (46% Francophone in 1996) also have significant Francophone populations.

Offhand, and without any conclusions which have been substantially backed up by scholarship, I'd say that there are four major differences between Ottawa and Moncton insofar as language use in their downtowns is concerned.
1. There are, in Ottawa's metropolitan area, large territories where Francophones predominate demographically (primarily the Québec side, secondarily enclaves on the Ontario side).
2. In the enclaves of the region's Francophone majority, legislative action (i.e. Québec's language laws) has given the French language greater status than a strict distribution of status according to demographic proportions would indicate.
3. There are simply many more Francophones living in greater Ottawa than in greater Moncton, and Ottawan francophones tend to be wealthier and better educated--hence, more resilient faced with assimilation--than their Monctonian counterparts.
4. Ottawa's an international city, on the frontier between English and French Canada. Somewhat like Montréal--and somewhat like Moncton's ideal--it's where the two major linguistic communities of Canada meet. This encounter includes the immigrants to both communities.

I just had to get this out of my system.




(Post a new comment)


[info]nire_nagaf
2004-02-23 07:36 pm UTC (link)
Last time I was in Ottawa, two years ago, I was struck by how many of the local people I encountered were francophone. Ottawa's job prospects also draw many commuters from the other side of the provincial border.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re:
[info]rfmcdpei
2004-02-23 08:30 pm UTC (link)
I heard French spoken quite frequently, in the streets and elsewhere. Not so much French-accented English, curiously.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]pauldrye
2004-02-23 09:28 pm UTC (link)
What's the physical arrangement of Moncton? I ask because Ottawa has the obvious geographic divide of the river through it, as well as the conceptual border running down the middle of the waterway. I'm guessing Moncton has no similar fractures.

I suspect a large part of the uneven distribution in Ottawa has to do with people mapping their mental sense of difference on to the physical and provincial division. Which is rather fascinating, if you think about it -- "This is our side, and that is yours. We should stay on our sides." -- all the more so because it's probably unconscious.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]rfmcdpei
2004-02-24 07:36 am UTC (link)
There's the Petitcodiac river, a tidal inlet that isn't that much of a geographic frontier--certainly not as much as the Ottawa. There's a bit of a linguistic division, with the regions to the north and east of the Petitcodiac being more Francophone than the other areas, but it hasn't struck me as particularly homogeneously Francophone on my visits.

Ottawa and Montreal have both struck me as authentically more bilingual than Moncton, despite that latter city's pretensions, probably because of the existence of boundaries. Perhaps if the Parti acadien managed to form an 11th province and Moncton became a biprovincial CMA we'd see a more bilingual Moncton?

(Reply to this) (Parent)


(Anonymous)
2004-02-24 08:23 am UTC (link)
I find it more common in Ottawa to hear a conversation flip from fluent french to fluent English, and back again than in Montreal.

Beyond the normal bilingualism of border areas, Ottawa bilingualism is given a fillip because of the gvt requirement for bilingualism for the best government jobs. Knowing this, the good burghers of Ottawa tend to send their kids to French language schools.

As for the territorial arrangements -- Anglophones tend to prefer living on the Ontario side becuase of the significantly lower taxes and the difficulties in getting English-language schooling on the Quebec side. Some francophones prefer living in Quebec (notwithstanding the tax differential) perhaps because of the considerably lower housing costs, and some don't.

(Had you gone to the west end of Ottawa (formerly Kanata) you would have seen absolutely no French. The tech world is all English. French is more common on the east side (formerly Orleans).)

Ottawa has a century old history of Levantine immigration (the Nasrallah family, the Daifallahs -- including the right wing journalist Adam Daifallah, the Bousheys) and this is the base of the considerable Arab population. It has also become, for no apparent reason, a centre for Somali-Canadians.

And, given our other conversations, I'm suprised you did not note the commonality of headscarves in Ottawa. In no other city in North America have I seen headscarves as often in Ottawa. The Levantine, Somali, and Bosnian communitiees have them as part of their cultural tradition, and even a few South Asians have adopted the practice.

I hope you had a good time at winterlude -- the ice sculpures were falling apart, but the snow sculptures were in good shape -- and I hope you make another trip up in the summer, to see what non-Siberian Ottawa has to offer.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]rfmcdpei
2004-02-24 01:59 pm UTC (link)
I find it more common in Ottawa to hear a conversation flip from fluent french to fluent English, and back again than in Montreal.

Perhaps the language situation in Ottawa is less paranoid, inasmuch as geographic boundaries exist and aren't at all likely to be contravened? Hull isn't going to be Anglicized, and the day when Ottawa becomes a Francophone city has to exist in an alternate history.

As for the territorial arrangements -- Anglophones tend to prefer living on the Ontario side becuase of the significantly lower taxes and the difficulties in getting English-language schooling on the Quebec side. Some francophones prefer living in Quebec (notwithstanding the tax differential) perhaps because of the considerably lower housing costs, and some don't.

I've talked to a couple of Francophones who've moved from the Québec to the Ontario side, and they've emphasized a relative permeability.

Ottawa has a century old history of Levantine immigration (the Nasrallah family, the Daifallahs -- including the right wing journalist Adam Daifallah, the Bousheys) and this is the base of the considerable Arab population. It has also become, for no apparent reason, a centre for Somali-Canadians.

The story behind this chain migration must be interesting. Did/does Somalia have an embassy in Canada?

And, given our other conversations, I'm suprised you did not note the commonality of headscarves in Ottawa. In no other city in North America have I seen headscarves as often in Ottawa. The Levantine, Somali, and Bosnian communitiees have them as part of their cultural tradition, and even a few South Asians have adopted the practice.

Perhaps it was a matter of timing? The Byward Market area was definitely ethnically and racially diverse, and I can only presume I saw more than a few Muslims in the absence of specific markers.

I hope you had a good time at winterlude -- the ice sculpures were falling apart, but the snow sculptures were in good shape -- and I hope you make another trip up in the summer, to see what non-Siberian Ottawa has to offer.

Of course. Well, assuming I've got some actual income and won't be living on a heating grate in Toronto.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…