Randy McDonald ([info]rfmcdpei) wrote,
@ 2005-06-07 22:28:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current music:Pet Shop Boys, "My October Symphony"

[BRIEF NOTE] The Fate of East Prussia
Back in 1999, the Neue Zürcher Zeitung published Rudolf Hermann's fascinating English-language article "East Prussia's Search for Identity: Gdansk, Kaliningrad and Klaipeda Since the Great Change" (Google's cached copy is here).. Strictly speaking, the use of the term "East Prussia" is inaccurate when referring to the period after the First World War, since Gdansk (then Danzig) became a Free City under the League of Nations while Klaipeda (then Memel) was annexed with its hinterland to the young Lithuanian republic.

In the days of the Second Reich, Danzig, Memel, and Königsberg were the easternmost enclaves of Germandom. The German states of these cities were threatened, not only geopolitically by the Russian Empire that nearly surrounded them, but demographically and ethnolinguistically by the relatively more fecund Poles, Lithuanians, and kindred peoples. The Ostflucht, the migration of ethnic Germans from the eastern reaches of the Prussian realm to richer areas in western and central Germany, began almost as soon as Germany was unified. The recreation of independent Polish and Lithuanian nation-states impinged directly upon East Prussia, which became a sovereign German island in a Balto-Slavic sea. Unsurprisingly, the failure of Nazi Germany's gambit to unite all Germans into a single nightmarish empire left East Prussia and its adjoining cities forfeit. Memel was renamed Klaipeda and restored to a post-war Lithuania now a Soviet republic; Danzig became Gdansk as part of its annexation to a Poland that now also included the Warminsko-Mazurskie Voivodship, the south of East Prussia; the core of East Prussia, around the devastated city of Königsberg, became the Russian republic's 'Калининград province (Kaliningrad in Latin script).

Hermann's survey of these three cities, though six years out of date. Gdansk's Poland and Klaipeda's Lithuania are rejoining their old circum-Baltic and European communities, and using the remaining continuities with the pre-1939 past as capital to support this reintegration. The city of Kaliningrad and its province, trapped by their peripheral geography within the Russian Federation, can't follow suit. It's likely going too far to claim that Kaliningrad could become a "black hole" inside the European Union, despite the province's serious serious HIV/AIDS epidemic and the growing gap opening between it and its neighbours. It does seem quite likely that Kaliningrad won't be able to capitalize as effectively on its East Prussian heritage as its neighbour cities.



(Post a new comment)


[info]dsgood
2005-06-08 02:41 am UTC (link)
"The German states of these cities were threatening [sic]...demographically and ethnolinguistically by the relatively more fecund Poles, Lithuanians, and kindred peoples."

As the primarily-anglophone city of Montreal was threatened by rural francophones. And as several Spanish-speaking cities in Central and South America are threatened by rural speakers of Native American languages.

Note: At one time, pan-Germanists wanted Slavs, Balts, Jews, Hungarians, etc. to become Germans. At some point, "bring them all in" became replaced by "weed out their grandchildren who are pretending to be Germans."

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]rfmcdpei
2005-06-09 02:06 am UTC (link)
It wasn't inevitable. It's ironic how the Nazis much aggravated the very trends they most feared.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


(Anonymous)
2005-06-08 06:15 am UTC (link)
I've been thinking that a post-1945 Jewish Soviet Socialist Republic in the Kaliningrad region would make a good alternate history scenario.

-Danny

(Reply to this)


(Anonymous)
2005-06-08 03:48 pm UTC (link)
I'm of the opinion that the EU ought to just buy the Kalinin area and turn it into a 'federal zone' like Washington DC and then move the capital there. That way you have the EU paying for a nontrivial amount of Russia's debt (which helps the Russians), a federal zone that's separate from any one nation in the EU, and a lotta money going in to rehabilitate a very dilapidated Oblast.

The Russians are very unlikely to go for this though. I had a discussion on usenet once with a Russian about the idea. He said Kalinin, the Kuriles, and some other places were absolutely necessary for the defense of Russia. I didn't quite grasp why and when I asked for a clarification as for why I didn't get it. However, with Kalinin I can understand to some extent since it was paid for in a lotta blood. So, it's not really a defense reason, AFAIK, but rather a national pride reason. I can't say I'd want to give up Alaska or Hawaii or the Marianas either.

(Reply to this)(Thread)

doh
(Anonymous)
2005-06-08 03:49 pm UTC (link)
That's me...

-Will

(Reply to this)(Parent)(Thread)

Re: doh
[info]rydel23
2005-06-09 06:35 pm UTC (link)
Why should they spend so much time and effort (probably on the scale of the International Space Station) in order to do that? They have enough internal troubles.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…